The fastest way to knock nine percent off a chip stock, it turns out, is a rumor about Apple's shopping list. Memory shares slid Monday morning after weekend reports, carried by 24/7 Wall St., that Washington may permit Apple to source DRAM from China's CXMT and NAND flash from YMTC, a move the reports describe as a possible diplomatic gesture ahead of a planned visit by President Xi Jinping expected around late September.
The tape reaction was uniform and unkind. SanDisk fell 9 percent to $1,458.29 in early trading, Micron dropped 7 percent to $897.86, Western Digital lost 7 percent to $429.49 and SK hynix gave up 5 percent, per the coverage, with a memory-sector ETF down 7 percent almost exactly in line with the individual names. When everything falls by the same amount, traders are selling the category rather than doing math on any one company, and the coverage notes these stocks had run hard enough this year, SanDisk up 572 percent and Micron up 239 percent through Friday's close, that a policy headline had plenty of altitude to work with.
Here is the part where qualification, the least glamorous word in electronics, earns its keep. A phone maker cannot simply swap memory suppliers the way a bakery swaps flour brands. Every part must be qualified, meaning months of testing that the chips hit density, power and reliability targets inside specific products. According to a note from Lynx Equity Research analyst KC Rajkumar cited in the coverage, CXMT is qualified for exactly one low-volume Mac product, is not qualified for iPhones at all, and shows poor yield on the high-density LPDDR5X DRAM Apple actually uses. YMTC's newest NAND, he found, is spoken for by domestic customers, from Android phones to electric vehicles and Lenovo notebooks.
Rajkumar's conclusion, as reported, is that the selloff overreacts to supply that mostly cannot show up. Apple, for its part, has said it is evaluating all options on memory sourcing, per the same coverage, with an eye on both supply and pricing.
There are also two names on a list worth knowing about. Both CXMT and YMTC appear on the Pentagon's Section 1260H roster of companies with alleged ties to China's military-industrial base, which would complicate any procurement plan, and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick told the Wall Street Journal earlier this month that American companies using Chinese memory is not a great outcome, in his words as reported by 24/7 Wall St..
The bet the market repriced on Monday is really a bet about leverage. Even a small qualified Chinese supply line would hand Apple a negotiating stick against Micron, Samsung and SK hynix at exactly the moment memory prices have been running away from buyers. Whether that stick can exist in the physical world of yields and qualification timelines is the question the selloff skipped, and the reason at least one analyst spent Monday telling clients to breathe.
Leave a Reply